Potential Hope for CFIDS/ME Patients with ICL
by Alan Cocchetto, NCF Medical Director ©2005
Over a decade ago, Dr. Paul Cheney, Dr. Anthony Komaroff
and other CFIDS/ME physicians had identified a condition known as
ICL in some of their patients. ICL is the acronym for "Idiopathic
CD4 Lymphocytopenia" and it denotes a dramatic loss of a specific
T-cell lymphocyte known as a CD4 (T-helper) cell. The
extensive reduction in CD4 cells is a hallmark characteristic of
AIDS, a disease characterized by a progressive loss of function of
the immune system.
Scientists at Enzon Pharmaceuticals have been studying the
mechanisms involved in CD4 depletion and have developed a potential
drug treatment for CD4 T-cell lymphopenia. Since ICL is typically
defined as a CD4 cell count below 200 cells/microliter, a condition
that unfortunately is present in some CFIDS/ME patients, this
treatment may offer a means to restore some of the immune
dysfunction that has occurred as a result of the disease process.
More importantly, it may provide a way to reduce opportunistic
infections that often accompany this illness since CD4 cells are
critical to appropriate immunologic response.
The NCF believes that scientific evidence points to CFIDS/ME as a
result of a chronic infection. As such, the immune system is
chronically activated due to this "unknown" infection. As a
consequence, this cellular activation must therefore play a vital
role in the pathology of this disease. Abnormal levels of RNaseL,
cellular apoptosis, etc. have been reported in CFIDS/ME and this
bolsters our beliefs here. Thus, a chronic infection certainly has
the potential to cause cellular depletion, as is seen in ICL, via
T-cell apoptosis. Scientists have discovered that some patients
with ICL have a deficiency in an important enzyme known as adenosine
deaminase.
A deficiency of adenosine deaminase (ADA) results in severe
combined immunodeficiency (SCID) in humans. ADA is an enzyme in the
purine degradation pathway that deaminates adenosine and
deoxyadenosine to yield inosine and deoxyinosine respectively.
The enzyme has a wide tissue distribution with the highest activity
occurring in lymphocytes. ADA deficiency inhibits the normal
catabolism of purines and results in the accumulation of metabolic
substrates that are especially toxic to lymphocytes. ADA deficiency
results in T-cell apoptosis (cell death) as well as an alteration to
T-cell differentiation and therefore an alteration in the production
of mature T-cells.
The good news is that a suggested drug treatment for ADA
deficiency is Adagen. Adagen (intramuscular injection) is a modified
enzyme used for enzyme replacement therapy for the treatment of SCID
associated with ADA deficiency. Adagen provides specific and direct
replacement of the deficient enzyme. Adagen administration can
eliminate the toxic metabolites of ADA deficiency and result in
improved immune function. However, it is imperative that treatment
with Adagen be carefully monitored by measurement of the level of
ADA activity in plasma. Monitoring of the level of deoxyadenosine
triphosphate (dATP) in erythrocytes is also helpful in determining
that the dose of Adagen is adequate.
The NCF is confident that PWC/ME patients that suffer from ICL
will be encouraged by this information.
References:
1. p53 expression is required for thymocyte apoptosis induced by
adenosine deaminase deficiency; Benveniste P, Cohen A; Proc Natl
Acad Sci 1995, Aug 29;92(18):8373-7
2. Adenosine deaminase and thymocyte maturation; Doherty PJ, Pan S,
Mulloy JC, Thompson E, Thorner P, Barankiewiecz J, Roifman CM, Cohen
A; Scand J Immunol 1991, Apr; 33(4):405-10
3. Mechanisms of apoptosis in developing thymocytes as revealed by
adenosine deaminase-deficient fetal thymic organ cultures; Thompson
LF, Vaughn JG, Laurent AB, Blackburn MR, Van De Wiele CJ; Biochem
Pharmacol 2003, Oct 15;66(8):1595-9
4. Fundamental Immunology; Raven Press; William Paul -
editor
5. Osler's Web: Inside the labyrinth of the Chronic Fatigue
Syndrome Epidemic; Hillary Johnson; Crown Publishers, 1996
6. Adagen injection PDR drug information;
http://www.drugs.com/PDR/Adagen_Injection.html
7. Method of treating CD4+ T cell lymphopenia in immuno-compromised
patients; US Patent #5,728,560 issued March 17, 1998 to Inventors:
Shorr RGL, Clark MA, Goddard DH; Assignee: Enzon, Inc.